Canada vs US Tax Rates: Who Pays More and Why
Canadians pay more income tax than Americans at most income levels. At the top, Ontario’s combined rate is 53.5%, against 37% in Texas and 50.3% in California. Sales tax runs higher in Canada too, with 13% HST in Ontario. The gap shrinks once you count US health insurance premiums, which Canadian income tax already covers through public healthcare.
At a combined federal-provincial/state level, Canadian rates usually run several percentage points higher than US rates at the same income, depending on the province, the state, and the income level, though a high-tax state like California can match or pass Ontario at some incomes. The gap narrows at lower incomes (where Canadian credits like the basic personal amount and GST/HST credit are relatively generous) and widens at the top, where Ontario reaches 53.5% combined against 37% in a state with no income tax. The gap also narrows in substance when healthcare, sales tax, and payroll taxes are factored in, because the Canadian rate covers publicly funded healthcare and the US rate does not.
Are taxes higher in Canada or the US?
Taxes are higher in Canada, and Canadians pay more at most income levels. Combined federal-provincial rates usually run several points above combined federal-state rates, sales tax is higher, and the OECD puts Canada’s 2024 tax take at 34.9% of GDP against 25.6% in the US. Americans pay for health insurance separately.
Not against every state, though: at $150,000, California ends up slightly above Ontario in the worked example below. The gap comes mostly from the provincial layer, and the tables below put numbers to each piece.
- At the federal level alone, the gap is narrower than most people expect: Canada’s 14% lowest bracket (reduced from 15% in mid-2025) sits between the US 12% and 22% rates and covers more income than the US 10% and 12% brackets combined, and the middle brackets track within a few points of each other until the top.
- The gap widens materially when provincial tax is added, because every Canadian province and territory levies an income tax (top rates for 2026 run from 11.5% in Nunavut to 21.8% in Newfoundland and Labrador, and 25.75% in Quebec) while nine US states have no tax on wages at all.
- The headline rate comparison also overstates the difference in practice: Canadian rates implicitly include publicly funded healthcare, while US rates do not, so a taxpayer moving from Ontario to Texas adds a health insurance premium that is invisible in the rate table.
How much are taxes in Canada?
Canadian income tax runs from 14% to 33% federally for 2026, plus a provincial or territorial tax on top. Combined top rates range from 44.5% in Nunavut to 54.8% in Newfoundland and Labrador. Sales tax adds 5% GST, or 13% to 15% HST in the harmonized provinces, plus CPP and EI deductions from pay.
- The 2026 provincial and territorial rates start between 4% (Nunavut) and 10.8% (Manitoba) and top out between 11.5% (Nunavut) and 21.8% (Newfoundland and Labrador). Quebec sets its own rates through Revenu Quebec.
- The federal basic personal amount ($16,452 for 2026) means the first slice of income carries no federal tax.
- GST/HST is 5% in Alberta (GST only), 5% plus 7% PST in BC, 5% plus 9.975% QST in Quebec, 13% HST in Ontario, 14% in Nova Scotia, and 15% in New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, and PEI.
Are taxes high in Canada?
Next to the US, yes. Next to other developed countries, Canada is close to average. The OECD puts Canada’s 2024 tax-to-GDP ratio at 34.9%, 21st of 38 member countries and just above the 34.1% OECD average. The US came in at 25.6%, 31st. Part of Canada’s higher take pays for public health care.
- The figures come from the OECD’s Revenue Statistics 2025 country notes for Canada and the United States. The 2024 numbers are provisional.
- Tax-to-GDP measures what a whole country collects, not what any one person pays. For an individual, the province, state and income level matter far more, which is what the rest of this guide compares.
What is the tax rate in Canada vs the US?
For 2026, federal income tax runs from 14% to 33% in Canada and 10% to 37% in the US. Add provincial or state tax and the top combined rate runs from 44.5% to 54.8% in Canada, against 37% (in states with no wage tax) to just over 50% (California, New York City) in the US.
Canada 2026 (federal only):
| Taxable income (CAD) | Rate |
|---|---|
| $0 - $58,523 | 14% |
| $58,523 - $117,045 | 20.5% |
| $117,045 - $181,440 | 26% |
| $181,440 - $258,482 | 29% |
| Over $258,482 | 33% |
The lowest federal rate was reduced from 15% to 14% effective July 1, 2025; 2026 is the first full year at the new rate. The basic personal amount ($16,452 for 2026) reduces the effective rate at the bottom. The first $16,452 of income is effectively taxed at 0% through the non-refundable credit.
US 2026 (federal only, single filer, post-OBBBA permanent TCJA rates):
| Taxable income (USD) | Rate |
|---|---|
| $0 - $12,400 | 10% |
| $12,400 - $50,400 | 12% |
| $50,400 - $105,700 | 22% |
| $105,700 - $201,775 | 24% |
| $201,775 - $256,225 | 32% |
| $256,225 - $640,600 | 35% |
| Over $640,600 | 37% |
The standard deduction ($16,100 for 2026 for a single filer) reduces taxable income, so the first $16,100 of gross income is effectively taxed at 0%.
At $100,000 of gross income (ignoring the exchange rate for simplicity), the Canadian federal rate on the top dollar is 20.5%, and the US federal rate is 22%. At $200,000, it is 29% vs 24%. At $300,000, it is 33% vs 35%. The federal-only gap is narrow at most income levels; Canada’s 14% lowest bracket is only a couple of points above the US 12% bracket, and the 20.5% second bracket tracks close to the US’s 22%. The gap widens above $117,045 CAD, where Canada’s 26% bracket runs against the US’s 24%, and above $181,440 CAD, where Canada’s 29% bracket sits five points above the US’s 24%. When provincial and state taxes are layered on (below), the combined Canadian rate exceeds the combined US rate at most levels.
Provincial and state taxes
This is where the comparison varies enormously. Canada has 13 provinces and territories, each with its own income tax brackets. The US has 50 states, 9 of which have no tax on wages (Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, Wyoming) and several others with flat rates.
Combined top marginal rates (selected, approximate):
| Jurisdiction | Combined top rate |
|---|---|
| Nova Scotia | 54.0% |
| Ontario | 53.5% |
| Quebec | 53.3% |
| British Columbia | 53.5% |
| Alberta | 48.0% |
| California | 50.3% (37% federal + 13.3% state) |
| New York (NYC) | 51.8% (37% federal + 10.9% state + 3.876% city) |
| Texas | 37.0% (federal only, no state tax) |
| Florida | 37.0% (federal only) |
| Washington | 37.0% (federal only, but a state capital gains tax of 7% on long-term gains above $278,000 for 2025, and 9.9% on the part over $1 million) |
Among the provinces in this table, the range runs from 48% (Alberta) to 54% (Nova Scotia), and Saskatchewan, not shown, is a touch lower than Alberta at 47.5%. Newfoundland and Labrador’s top combined rate (54.8%, on income over about $1.14 million) is the highest in the country. The range in the US is 37% (no-tax states) to over 50% (California, at the highest brackets). Moving from Ontario to Texas produces a large rate drop. Moving from Alberta to California produces a smaller one, or potentially none at the highest incomes.
How much more tax do you pay in Canada than in the US?
It varies by income level, province, and state, but at a typical middle-to-upper income of $150,000, a single filer in Ontario pays roughly $45,500 in combined income tax and mandatory payroll contributions for 2026, while the same filer in Texas pays roughly $36,200 ($24,700 of federal income tax plus about $11,500 of Social Security and Medicare), a difference of about $9,300.
- Replace Texas with California and the gap disappears at this income. The same filer owes roughly $9,600 of California income tax and $1,950 of California State Disability Insurance (1.3% for 2026, with no wage cap) on top of the Texas figures, about $47,800 in all, roughly $2,300 more than in Ontario. California’s 9.3% bracket, which covers most of this filer’s income, does most of the work.
- Replace Ontario with Alberta (48% combined at the top, one of the lowest among the provinces) and the gap from Texas narrows less than you might expect, because Alberta’s top combined rate (48%) still exceeds the US federal-only rate (37%) by 11 points.
- The worked comparison below runs through both sides at $150,000 with the underlying math visible, and the caveats (healthcare, sales tax, credits, exchange rate) follow in the later sections.
A worked comparison at $150,000
To make the comparison concrete, here is a rough calculation for a single filer earning $150,000 in employment income, comparing Ontario to Texas. Exchange rate effects are ignored (the comparison uses the nominal amounts in each currency).
Ontario ($150,000 CAD):
- Federal tax (after basic personal credit): approximately $25,300
- Ontario provincial tax (including surtax and the $600 health premium that applies at this income): approximately $14,500
- CPP and CPP2 contributions (employee share): approximately $4,650
- EI premiums: approximately $1,120
- Total income tax + payroll: approximately $45,500
- Effective rate: approximately 30%
- Healthcare: covered by OHIP, no separate premium (funded through general revenue)
Texas ($150,000 USD):
- Federal tax (after standard deduction): approximately $24,700
- State tax: $0
- Social Security (employee share, 6.2% on first $184,500 for 2026): approximately $9,300
- Medicare (employee share, 1.45%): approximately $2,175
- Total income tax + payroll: approximately $36,200
- Effective rate: approximately 24%
- Healthcare: employer-sponsored plan; KFF’s 2025 survey puts the average worker share of the premium at $1,440 a year for single coverage and $6,850 for family coverage, plus deductibles and copays
The headline tax numbers aren’t close: approximately 30% in Ontario vs 24% in Texas. But the Ontario number includes universal healthcare. The Texas number needs the worker’s share of health insurance added (about $1,440 single or $6,850 family on average) plus out-of-pocket medical costs. For a single employee with a typical employer plan that narrows the gap but doesn’t close it; for a family with heavy medical use, or someone buying coverage without an employer, the all-in burden can come out close.
At higher incomes ($300,000+), the gap widens because Ontario’s top rate (53.5%) runs well above the federal-only US rate (37% in Texas). At that level, the healthcare cost difference is proportionally smaller relative to the tax difference.
How are capital gains taxed in Canada vs the US?
Canada includes 50% of capital gains in income, at every level of gain. The 2024 budget proposed raising that to two-thirds above $250,000 a year, but the increase was cancelled in March 2025 and never took effect. The included portion is taxed at the taxpayer’s marginal rate.
The US taxes long-term capital gains (assets held over one year) at preferential rates: 0%, 15%, or 20% depending on income. Short-term gains (held one year or less) are taxed at ordinary rates.
For a $100,000 long-term capital gain:
- Ontario: $50,000 included in income (50% inclusion), taxed at the marginal rate. At a combined rate of approximately 43% on the included portion, tax is approximately $21,500.
- Texas: $100,000 taxed at the 15% long-term rate (for most filers in this range), plus potentially 3.8% NIIT. Tax is approximately $15,000 to $18,800.
The US treatment of long-term capital gains is generally more favorable. Canada’s 50% inclusion can beat it at low marginal rates, but the US preferential rate wins at most income levels. For the full breakdown (rates, exemptions, and what happens when both countries tax the same gain), see capital gains tax: Canada vs the US compared.
Sales tax and consumption taxes
Canada has the GST (5% federal) plus provincial sales tax (PST) or the harmonized HST (13% in Ontario, 14% in Nova Scotia since April 1, 2025, and 15% in New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, and PEI). Quebec has QST (9.975% on top of GST). Alberta has no provincial sales tax (GST only, 5%).
US state sales taxes range from 0% (Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, Oregon) to around 10% in the highest-rate places once local taxes are included (Louisiana, Tennessee, Arkansas, Alabama and Washington have the highest combined rates).
The Canadian sales tax rate is generally higher than the US rate, and it applies to more goods and services. The GST/HST credit partially offsets this for lower-income Canadians.
Payroll taxes
Canada: CPP contributions (5.95% employee, 5.95% employer, on earnings between $3,500 and $74,600 for 2026) plus CPP2 (4% each on earnings between $74,600 and $85,000) plus EI (1.63% employee, 2.28% employer, on earnings up to $68,900; Quebec uses QPP and a lower EI rate).
US: Social Security (6.2% employee, 6.2% employer, on earnings up to $184,500 for 2026) plus Medicare (1.45% employee, 1.45% employer, no cap, plus 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax on earnings above $200,000).
The US Social Security wage base is much higher than the CPP ceiling, so higher earners pay more payroll tax on the US side. But the CPP2 extension and the EI cap create a smaller layered effect in Canada.
What does the rate comparison miss?
The headline rate comparison misses several factors that affect the actual financial outcome: healthcare, child benefits, education costs, and retirement structures.
-
Healthcare. Canadian rates fund universal healthcare. US rates do not. Per KFF’s 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey, the average total premium for employer coverage is $9,325 for single coverage and $26,993 for family coverage, of which the worker pays on average $1,440 and $6,850, plus deductibles, copays, and out-of-network costs. This is not a tax, but it is a mandatory expense that Canadians do not bear separately.
-
Child benefits. Canada’s CCB (Canada Child Benefit) provides tax-free monthly payments of up to $8,157 a year per child under 6 and $6,883 per child 6 to 17 (July 2026 to June 2027 payment year, income-tested). The US child tax credit is $2,200 per qualifying child for 2025 and 2026 (up to $1,700 of it refundable for 2026; raised from $2,000 by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act). For families with children, the Canadian benefit is more generous at most income levels.
-
Education. Canadian tuition is generally lower than US tuition, and Canadian student loans have more favorable terms. This is not a tax comparison, but it affects the total cost of living in each country.
-
Retirement. CPP provides a defined benefit pension. Social Security provides a defined benefit pension. The structures differ, but both exist, and which one to claim first depends on your situation. Supplementary savings vehicles (RRSP vs 401(k)/IRA) have similar tax treatment.
What should I do next?
If you are comparing the two countries for a potential move, start with your specific province and state, your specific income level, and your family structure. Include healthcare costs, child benefits, and payroll taxes in the comparison, not just income tax rates. The headline rate difference is real, but the all-in difference is smaller (and sometimes reversed) when you include everything.
-
Moving from Ontario to Florida: taxes, a specific corridor comparison
-
Moving from BC to California: taxes, a high-tax-to-high-tax comparison
-
Moving from Toronto to New York: taxes, the highest-tax US destination
-
Leaving Canada permanently: a tax checklist, the full move checklist
-
Moving from Canada to Colorado: taxes, a low flat-rate state corridor
-
Moving from Canada to Maryland, a graduated-rate state near DC with county surcharges
-
Moving from Canada to Minnesota, one of the highest-tax US states (up to 9.85%)
-
Cross-border tax by city: Toronto (Ontario surtax, probate fees, double land transfer tax), Vancouver (foreign buyer tax, speculation tax, tech corridor), Calgary (lower top rate, no PST, oil and gas), Montreal (Revenu Quebec, QPP, QST), Florida (snowbird pipeline, homestead, domicile)
-
Income splitting: Canada vs US, pension splitting, spousal RRSP, and the strategies that reduce the rate gap
-
Standard deduction vs itemizing for cross-border filers, the deductions that change the effective rate comparison
-
Currency conversion and exchange rates, the rate rules that make the two countries’ numbers comparable
-
Cross-border charitable giving, when donating across the border changes the deduction math
Start with a Diagnostic: a CPA licensed in the US and Canada reads your file and tells you in writing what's wrong and how to fix it, three to four business days after you finish the questions. The report is $250. If you hire us for any work after that, you get the $250 back as a discount on that work. Or send us your return or your letter and get a fixed price, free.
One or two plain-English guides a week on US-Canada tax. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Done. The next guide will land in your inbox.
Yarik Yarosh, CPA. "Canada vs US Tax Rates: Who Pays More and Why." Blue Cloud CPA, August 21, 2026, updated November 19, 2026. https://bluecloudcpa.com/guides/canada-vs-us-tax-rates-comparison
This guide is general information, not tax advice for your specific situation. Which points apply, and how, depends on your facts.